Clear light orange body with minimal head. Aroma is sweet, caramel, and a hint of rye. Taste is much the same, but also with noticeable alcohol. Medium/full body. Not sure what the other raters saw, but one possibility is that, if in fact it's really a winter seasonal, perhaps it's been on tap all this time and the flavor's been lost.

Light and honeyish, some lacing. Caramel nose, slightly astringent; some detergent? Yum. More character than most of the others, though that doesn't say much. Where's the rye?

Clean light copper color with a small but stable beige head. Aroma of sweet munich malt and light honey. Frim with a slightly oily feel. Clean malt flavors with a balanced floral hops flavor. A pleasent brew.

The body poured with a hazy dark gold and orange color. The aroma was a little rye with some carrots and a little bit of honey. The taste was sweet rye bread with some honey. There was also some nasty apple cor ein the finish.

Copper color wtih no head. Aroma is a little hard to pin down: Apple? Pumpkin? Taste has a bit of bitter rye to it, but not much else.