 satan165 (207), River Grove, Illinois, USA
Sep 2, 2008
not half bad! and i dont even like lagers. flavor cut through everything my mouth had predisposed towards negativity towards this brewery, the style and more. and believe you me, there is plenty of animosity there. grassy and earthy, this isnt half bad. holds little interest for me personally but seems to be balanced to some extent, maybe magic hat should just give up on ales altogether.
eaglefan538 (2141), Wilmington, Delaware, USA
Jan 4, 2009 Bottle. Poured like a semi-hazy full bodied american pale lager. Decent carbonation, pilsner looking. The aroma was bitter hops, resinous notes, grainy malts. The flavor followed the aroma, like an English Pale Ale, really (if I didn’t read that it was a lager), some adjuncts mixed in there with the earthy bitter hops, one of the most bitter-hopped "pale lagers" I’ve seen, shy of a pilsner grass level, though. Meh, it was ok, but I don’t get it, why bother with this style, MH? Craft brew or not. Well short of anything really pilsner-like, a fully flavored, top of the line pale lager, for whatever that’s worth!
FunkyBrewster (241), Chicago, Illinois, USA
Dec 29, 2008 Thanks 17thfloor! Pours a slightly hazy orange with a small off-white froth. Aroma is a blend of malts and hops. Some definite fruity citrusy hops provide a sharp aroma that is balanced by some caramel and light malts. Flavor starts out with a burst of lively citrus fruitiness but quickly picks up the hops which provide a sharp slightly piney bitterness that gains in strength through the finish. Finishes with a slight return of sweet malt and wheat in the aftertaste. Medium bodied and moderate carbonation. A decent lager that has a certain level of balance but doesnt bring any great complexity or character to the table. Not sure that itd get me out to vote. (I did vote)
cheapdark (1683), Monacatootha, Pennsylvania, USA
Dec 23, 2008 Smells like a hoppy pale lager. Color of pale lager but a little hazey. Hey this says it’s a lager but it immediately comes across like an IPA or imperial pilsner, hweoooo. Disappointing IPA character, that is because I don’t like IPA. Any carbonation is covered by the green grapefruit rind bitterness. Dude! I probably should have got the message on the label because participation has IPA in the word. Lingering nasty IPA finish. On IPA style, bordering on DPA. PARTICIPATION S5L3T3F203
Bella68 (31), Alabama, USA
Dec 1, 2008 Bottle. This lager had the most amazing head I’ve ever seen. Very billowy and everlasting. Color was a golden amber and clear. Unfortunately, I didn’t get much out of the aroma, but the taste wasn’t bad. Kinda grainy and medium bodied. Pretty fun lager.
Jine (885), Nutley, New Jersey, USA
Nov 30, 2008 11.16.08 Pretty decent pils but not as good as the Victory I had just before. Good though, Magic Hat doesn’t disappoint.
|
