fidelis83 (729), Clinton, Iowa, USA
| 4.1 | Aroma | Appearance | Flavor | Palate | Overall | | 9/10 | 3/5 | 8/10 | 4/5 | 17/20 | Oct 19, 2009 Pours dark ruby-brown with a 1 finger, creamy beige head, that has o.k. retention. Aroma is roast, maple and oak campfire, sweet balsamic notes (light on the vinegarcharacteristics), oak, light earthiness, rye bread, chocolate chip cookies, habanero peppers, apple pie filling, tart berries and dark fruits. This stuff just conjures up all kinds of scents, it’s all over the place but in a very good, complex, well rounded way. Flavor is smoked malt, balsamic vinegar, chocolate chip cookie dough, dusty old oak planks, toasted rye bread, sourdough bread crust, some definite lactic sourness, light caramel, some stale coffee, toffee, mixed nuts, peanut skins and a little earthy funk. Finish is smoke, toasted malt, a lingering sourness for a good long time, old oak and some mineral notes. As it warms it gets a little sweeter and the caramel, oak and chocolate notes come out alot more. Palate is light to medium bodied with a sharp, champagne like carbonation, a little acidic tingle, a slightly creamy entry and a very dry finish. From reading other’s descriptions it seems like a love-it-or-hate-it brew, after drinking it, I can totally understand the polarized opinions. Chalk another one up for the love it side. Awesome stuff, I could definitely drink this every day, hopefully I can find time to pick up some more to keep around befor it runs out.
shp555 (1698), Atlanta, Georgia, USA
| 3.4 | Aroma | Appearance | Flavor | Palate | Overall | | 6/10 | 3/5 | 6/10 | 3/5 | 16/20 | Jan 2, 2010 Pours a deep amber color with a tan head. Aroma is smoky, nutty, berry, and tart. Flavor is malty, nutty, smoky, slightly buttery, and a tart fruity finish. Sparky27 (1642), Phoenix, Arizona, USA
| 3 | Aroma | Appearance | Flavor | Palate | Overall | | 6/10 | 3/5 | 6/10 | 3/5 | 12/20 | Dec 30, 2009 Bottle shared by Bockyhorsey at the Black Friday tasting – thanks Bill! Pours cloudy dark brown with a thin tan head. The nose is cocoa, caramel and roasted nuts. The taste is sour lactic upfront with malt and light chocolate in the finish. Too sour for a porter ditmier (1119), Boise, Idaho, USA
| 2.7 | Aroma | Appearance | Flavor | Palate | Overall | | 4/10 | 3/5 | 5/10 | 3/5 | 12/20 | Dec 30, 2009 2009 Bottle - Forget who sent this one but thanks! Pours a clear dk amber with a medium off white head...aroma is not good, musty woody vinegar, lt coffee and cocoa malt...I’m having a very hard time here, I honestly cannot tell if this is the intentionally soured end result or if something is hitching a ride...flavour is acidic white wine vinegar, creme cafe, some toffee malt sweets behind the sourness...I do honestly believe that Dan Carey is the new Jesus and I love (almost) everything he does, but this style, while quite interesting, is definitely something that did not need reproduction in my opinion...
Half an hour later...it’s growing on me a bit, less vinegar, more malt showing up, more cocoa and coffee, maybe something good with fish and chips... Radek Kliber (4000), Toronto (Can) Krotoszyn (Pol), Ontario, Canada
| 2.2 | Aroma | Appearance | Flavor | Palate | Overall | | 5/10 | 3/5 | 2/10 | 1/5 | 11/20 | Dec 30, 2009 Bottle 355? ml
Appearance : hazed amber-brown with rocky top. Nose: lactic coffee , almonds on top , slight peppery feel. Flavor/Palate : Funky , citric , sour , grainy chewy textured. Old school porter with all its faults?
travita (1970), Frisco, Texas, USA
| 3.7 | Aroma | Appearance | Flavor | Palate | Overall | | 8/10 | 3/5 | 8/10 | 3/5 | 15/20 | Dec 29, 2009 Bottle thanks to bman1113vr. The smell is caramel, dessert, nuts, coffee, and cocoa. The look is clear, light brown in color, and light beige color in color. The taste is caramel, tart, like a weird tart sweet roasty coffee dessert. Different but nice. SledgeJr (3004), Omaha, Nebraska, USA
| 1.9 | Aroma | Appearance | Flavor | Palate | Overall | | 3/10 | 3/5 | 3/10 | 3/5 | 7/20 | Dec 28, 2009 In the bottle at Phil and Bernie’s holiday stout tasting. Pours brown with a slightly off-white head. This is positively crap beer. Very sour with almost no other redeeming features. I am not sure what they were trying to prove by making a beer so inappropriately named. Perhaps if one searched deeply you might find subtle cherry flavors but it is mostly a drain pour. bu11zeye (5675), Frisco, Texas, USA
| 3.7 | Aroma | Appearance | Flavor | Palate | Overall | | 8/10 | 3/5 | 7/10 | 4/5 | 15/20 | Dec 28, 2009 ( 12oz bottle, courtesy of BMan1113VR ) Pours a clear amber body with a small off-white head. Aroma of cocoa, caramel, roasted malt, ash, and smoke. Flavor of cocoa, smoke, light cherry syrup, raisins, and roasted malt. Syd (911), Waconia, Minnesota, USA
| 3.6 | Aroma | Appearance | Flavor | Palate | Overall | | 7/10 | 3/5 | 6/10 | 3/5 | 17/20 | Dec 26, 2009 Really amusing how the previous three raters were hoping their bottles were infected. Obviously they don’t read. I can understand if they don’t like it, but to imply that something is wrong misses the point. Yes, it is sour - it is supposed to be (I’ll save the rant to the product description listed above). Dark pour with ruby highlights, not much head. The aroma is very roasted and almost smoky. The flavor is surprisingly sour, roasted, with some sweetness to attempt to balance it out. The palate is fairly rich and pretty carbonated. Overall, while I prefer a nice modern interpretation of the style (apparently incorrect), I do appreciate this in the historical context. Thanks Dan for ALL you do...
|