Where do you buy your beer?

Reads 1837 • Replies 20 • Started Thursday, February 23, 2017 5:40:19 PM CT

The forums you're viewing are the static, archived version. You won't be able to post or reply here.
Our new, modern forums are here:
RateBeer Forums

Thread Frozen
 
fiulijn
beers 28379 º places 745 º 17:40 Thu 2/23/2017

In the last few months I collected some data when shopping for beer.
I put it up in a spreadsheet, and did some comparison.

The data
Collection of data over a few months, so some price may have changed.
I randomly chose some beers that are more likely to be available at multiple stores, local and imports, but I mostly avoided Vancouver beers.
Prices include taxes (as prices should always do), and no deposit.
Prices are listed as-is, no discounts taken into consideration, as they are not accessible to everybody (Camra requires membership; Friends&Family is 10%, Rep is 15%, Employee is 20%; Legacy has a membership system that gives effective 5% discount but you need to buy more; High Point has a membership system that gives progressive discount etc.)
Some BCL/LDB prices have been added just for reference, they are not used int he calculation.

The process
I take into consideration only prices when I have at least N samples (currently 3; you can see that in cell Q4).
Changing that parameter gives different numbers, but not different message.

Data link

 
fiulijn
beers 28379 º places 745 º 17:40 Thu 2/23/2017

This is how it looks like, from the most expensive (Viti on Nanaimo) to the most reasonable (The Gull in North Van)


(edit: I added some more data just now and Libation, as I suspected, climbed up to a worse position)

 
fiulijn
beers 28379 º places 745 º 17:42 Thu 2/23/2017

The number in the chart is only an indicator.
In order to have a direct comparison, I calculate the "basket" for the items that two shops both sell, and then compare one shop directly to the other.
In this way we can see, for example, that shopping at Brewery Creek is 11% more expensive than Legacy; at Denman is 4.8% more expensive than Legacy; and comparing worst to best, at Viti on Nanaimo beer is 20.1% more expensive than The Gull...

Link

 
Ferris
beers 23108 º places 1878 º 09:28 Fri 2/24/2017

How about running the numbers with the CAMRA discount? As some offer it and some don’t at different %.

I’d be curious to see if it evens the playing field or further separates everyone.

It is a cheap membership and most beer geeks in the city do have it or should.

 
fiulijn
beers 28379 º places 745 º 12:08 Fri 2/24/2017

Originally posted by fiulijn
Prices are listed as-is, no discounts taken into consideration, as they are not accessible to everybody (Camra requires membership; Friends&Family is 10%, Rep is 15%, Employee is 20%; Legacy has a membership system that gives effective 5% discount but you need to buy more; High Point has a membership system that gives progressive discount etc.)

 
fiulijn
beers 28379 º places 745 º 15:23 Fri 2/24/2017

For the record, I do have camra membership

 
Ferris
beers 23108 º places 1878 º 12:27 Sat 2/25/2017

Originally posted by fiulijn
Originally posted by fiulijn
Prices are listed as-is, no discounts taken into consideration, as they are not accessible to everybody (Camra requires membership; Friends&Family is 10%, Rep is 15%, Employee is 20%; Legacy has a membership system that gives effective 5% discount but you need to buy more; High Point has a membership system that gives progressive discount etc.)



A ’no’ would have sufficed.

 
Ferris
beers 23108 º places 1878 º 12:28 Sat 2/25/2017

Originally posted by fiulijn
For the record, I do have camra membership


For whose record?

 
CapFlu
beers 5136 º places 238 º 15:06 Sun 2/26/2017

I don’t usually buy my beer in Vancouver. Can you do one up for Victoria, Alex?

 
DuffMan
beers 10981 º places 349 º 16:01 Sun 2/26/2017

At the gas station, like normal people.

 
fiulijn
beers 28379 º places 745 º 14:23 Tue 2/28/2017

Originally posted by CapFlu
I don’t usually buy my beer in Vancouver. Can you do one up for Victoria, Alex?

When I visited a couple of years ago I was impressed by how low prices are in Victoria compared to Vancouver... I hope that’s still the same